Battery Mixer Makers: 20 Firms by Mixing Method

A battery mixer is the machine that turns active material, conductive additive, binder and solvent into electrode slurry. The right basis for comparing mixer makers is the mixing method, not the brand. The mixing method decides shaft deflection, clearance wear and metal-contamination risk. This article groups 20 mixer and dispersion equipment makers verified from public sources into four mixing methods, and checks by calculation the mechanical risk that comes with scale-up.

Problem Definition

Batch planetary mixers dominate battery slurry mixing. Korean makers have scaled up from the 1,300 L and 2,300 L classes to a 4,000 L UDM mixer (per Yunsung F&C public materials). In the same period, continuous twin-screw lines emerged as an alternative.

The contradiction is this. A larger vessel needs a longer agitator shaft. Shaft deflection grows with the cube of length. The clearance between blade and vessel wall cannot grow much without hurting mixing. So what should be asked first when comparing makers? Our answer: the ratio of clearance to deflection, and the calculation behind it.

Kinematic Analysis — Four Mixing Methods

Mixing methodDominant load and wearMechanical riskMakers
Batch planetary (PD, double planetary)Combined rotation and revolution; cantilever shafts hanging from the top gearboxBlade-wall contact from shaft deflection; vacuum seal wearTSI, Yunsung F&C, Jeil M&S, Qinhuangdao Pengyi, Ross, NETZSCH
Continuous twin-screwScrew-barrel shear; metered feedingScrew and barrel clearance wear; wear debris as metal contaminationGMK, Bühler
Wet grinding and dispersion (bead mill, attritor, immersion mill)Media impact and shearMedia and liner wear; screen cloggingShanghai ELE, Union Process, Hockmeyer, NETZSCH
High-shear dispersion, kneader reactorTight rotor-stator gap; high-viscosity kneading torqueRotor gap control; high-torque drive trainAdmix, IKA, LIST Technology, CNT Solution

Full-line turnkey makers (Wuxi Lead, Yinghe, Gelon LIB) supply the mixer as part of a line. In that case the comparison is not the mixer alone. It is the scope of interface responsibility between the mixer and the feeding and slurry storage equipment. Great Wall Mixers builds industrial agitators and Xiamen TOB builds laboratory equipment, so both sit in different classes.

Maker Comparison Table

The table lists only what each maker discloses on its official website, in filings (DART, Shenzhen Stock Exchange annual reports and similar) or in company press releases. Revenue estimates from third-party data services were excluded because of low reliability. Makers that could not be cross-checked against public primary sources were left out. Makers with a detailed profile are linked.

MakerHQMain methodDisclosed factsBasis
TSI Co., Ltd.Hwaseong, KoreaBatch planetary (Corona mixer)KOSDAQ 277880. 2024 consolidated revenue KRW 272.0 billion, operating profit KRW 15.6 billion. Order backlog about KRW 558.9 billion at end of June 2025DART filings, press
Yunsung F&CAnseong, KoreaBatch PD and UDM; continuous in developmentKOSDAQ 372170. 4,000 L UDM mixer developed; 35 LPM continuous national project; mixing systems supplied to SK OnCompany website, Electronic Times
Jeil M&SIcheon, Korea (plant in Gimhae)Batch; continuous and dry mixers in developmentFounded 1981. Supplied Samsung SDI, LG Energy Solution and Northvolt. Press reports about KRW 30 billion receivables after Northvolt’s bankruptcyDealsite, Asia Economy
CNT SolutionKoreaCNT wet and dry dispersionFounded 2011. Supplies pre-dispersion technology for conductive additivesElectronic Times
Wuxi Lead IntelligentWuxi, ChinaFull-line turnkey (mixing to PACK)ChiNext 300450. Claims over 60% share in core equipment (company claim). Lists CATL, Tesla and Northvolt as customersCompany website, annual report
Yinghe TechnologyShenzhen, ChinaFront-to-back cell equipmentChiNext 300457; first listed lithium battery equipment maker in China (2015). 2025 revenue CNY 9.445 billion2025 annual report
GMK (Foshan Golden Milky Way)Foshan, ChinaContinuous twin-screw (GMK3.0)ChiNext 300619. 2025 operating revenue up 27.90% year on year; net profit about CNY 80.71 millionAnnual report summary (2026-04)
Great Wall MixersWenzhou, ChinaCorrosion- and wear-resistant industrial agitatorsNEEQ 839894. Started in 1993 as a gear reducer plant; four national 863 Program projectsNEEQ filings, company website
Qinhuangdao PengyiQinhuangdao, ChinaVacuum double planetary, sand millFounded 2009Company website
Shanghai ELEShanghai, ChinaSand mill, high-speed disperser, planetaryFounded 1996Company website
Gelon LIBLinyi and Dongguan, ChinaMaterials, equipment, turnkey linesStarted 2003. Exports lithium battery turnkey linesCompany website
Xiamen TOBXiamen, ChinaLaboratory and pilot equipmentSupplies lab battery equipment, coaters and testersCompany website
BühlerUzwil, SwitzerlandContinuous twin-screw113 systems supplied over 10 years, over 70 of them to China (as of 2026-02). About 56 kWh per tonne of slurry (company figure)Company newsroom
NETZSCHSelb, GermanyPlanetary (PMH), wet grinding2023 order from Fraunhofer FFB worth a double-digit million eurosCompany newsroom
IKAStaufen, GermanyInline dispersion (magic PLANT)Family company founded 1910Company catalog
LIST TechnologyArisdorf, SwitzerlandKneader reactor (solvent-free)Founded 1966. Merged into BUSSLIST Group in 2026Company press release
Ross (Charles Ross & Son)Hauppauge, USADual planetary disperserFounded 1842, employee-owned. Two production sites in Wuxi, ChinaCompany website
HockmeyerElizabeth City, USAImmersion millFounded 1943. Particle size reduction below 100 nmCompany website
Union ProcessAkron, USAAttritor (stirred ball mill)Founded 1946; developer of the AttritorCompany data sheet
AdmixLondonderry, USAHigh-shear dispersion (Rotosolver)Founded 1989, employee-ownedCompany website

Korean makers — the race to larger batch mixers

TSI states that its Corona mixer, developed in 2016, halves the installation footprint compared with a PD mixer. Yunsung F&C localized the PD mixer and then developed a 4,000 L UDM mixer, while running a 35 LPM continuous-mixing national project and a dry-electrode compound mixer targeted for 2027. Jeil M&S is a first-generation localizer founded in 1981. Press reports say Northvolt’s bankruptcy left about KRW 30 billion in receivables and led to a KRW 19 billion convertible bond issue. The case shows that supplier financial stability, not only machine performance, decides how long after-sales service lasts.

All three focus on large batch mixers. The mechanical issue of large batch mixers is shaft deflection, covered in the calculation below.

Chinese makers — continuous lines and full-line turnkey

GMK promotes its multi-stage twin-screw continuous line for cathode and anode slurry (GMK3.0). Wuxi Lead supplies full lines from mixing to PACK. Yinghe was the first lithium battery equipment maker to list in China, in 2015. Great Wall Mixers began as a gear reducer plant in 1993 and extended its reducer and shaft design experience to corrosion- and wear-resistant battery agitators. Qinhuangdao Pengyi and Shanghai ELE supply planetary mixers together with sand mills.

A continuous twin-screw line avoids the long cantilever shaft by design. In exchange, wear widens the screw-barrel clearance, which changes shear conditions and puts wear debris into the slurry. When evaluating continuous mixing, check the wear measurement method and replacement interval before deflection.

European and US makers — transferring grinding and dispersion know-how

Bühler combined dosing, kneading, dispersion and degassing in one process on a twin-screw platform derived from food extruders. NETZSCH supplies both planetary mixers and wet grinding and won a Fraunhofer FFB line in 2023. Ross builds dual planetary dispersers at its Wuxi sites. Hockmeyer developed the immersion mill, and Union Process developed the Attritor in 1946. What they share is the transfer of paint, chemical and pharmaceutical dispersion know-how to battery slurry. The depth of battery references differs by maker, so battery delivery cases should be checked separately.

Calculation and Formula Check — Scale-up and Shaft Deflection

The blade shaft of a planetary mixer is a cantilever hanging from the top gearbox. The first scale-up variable is blade tip speed.

$$v = \frac{\pi D n}{60000}$$

$v$ is tip speed (m/s), $D$ is blade swept diameter (mm) and $n$ is speed (rpm). With D=1,000 mm and n=60 rpm, v=3.14 m/s (example values). Keeping the same tip speed while increasing D to 1,600 mm lowers n to 37.5 rpm. The slurry reaction on the blade does not drop with the lower speed.

Shaft deflection and bending stress follow the cantilever equations.

$$\delta = \frac{F L^{3}}{3 E I}, \qquad I = \frac{\pi d^{4}}{64}, \qquad \sigma_b = \frac{32 F L}{\pi d^{3}}$$

$\delta$ is tip deflection (mm), $F$ is lateral blade load (N), $L$ is overhang length (mm), $E$ is elastic modulus (N/mm²), $I$ is second moment of area (mm⁴), $d$ is shaft diameter (mm) and $\sigma_b$ is bending stress (N/mm²). The safety factor is checked twice.

$$SF_1 = \frac{\sigma_y}{\sigma_b} \ge 2, \qquad SF_2 = \frac{c}{\delta} \ge 2$$

$\sigma_y$ is yield strength (N/mm²) and $c$ is blade-to-wall clearance (mm). Conditions: STS304 shaft (E=193,000 N/mm², yield strength 205 N/mm², KS D 3706 minimum), d=100 mm, F=2,000 N, c=5 mm. F and c are assumed values; re-confirm after on-site measurement.

Check itemL=1,500 mm, d=100 mmL=3,000 mm, d=100 mmL=3,000 mm, d=170 mm
Deflection δ (mm)2.3819.02.27
Bending stress σb (N/mm²)30.661.112.4
SF1 (strength)6.73.416.5
SF2 (clearance/deflection)2.10.262.2
ResultPassStrength pass, deflection failPass

Doubling the overhang doubles bending stress but multiplies deflection by eight. At L=3,000 mm, SF1 is 3.4 and strength passes. But the 19.0 mm deflection exceeds the 5 mm clearance, and the blade hits the wall. The shaft diameter of a large mixer is set by deflection, not strength. Meeting SF2 of 2 or more needs d of at least 166 mm. At 170 mm, SF2 becomes 2.2, but shaft mass per unit length rises about 2.9 times. The gearbox output bearing load must then be re-checked.

Practical Application (Shop-notes)

  • When comparing quotations, ask for the blade-to-vessel clearance c together with a deflection calculation at operating load. If SF2 is below 2, do not treat the machine as the same class even at the same capacity.
  • Machinability: long shafts with a high slenderness ratio (L/d) need a steady rest on the lathe, and chatter disturbs roundness. Leave final grinding allowance on blade and bearing seats to absorb distortion after blade welding.
  • Hollow shaft check: removing the core while keeping the outer diameter reduces mass but barely reduces the second moment of area. From $I_h = \pi (d^{4}-d_i^{4})/64$, an inner diameter $d_i$ of 50% of the outer diameter reduces I by only 6.25%. Increase the outer diameter first for deflection, and consider a hollow shaft only to cut mass and inertia.
  • Alternative mechanism — a foot bearing at the vessel bottom: turning the cantilever into a shaft supported at both ends cuts deflection sharply. Not adopted because a bearing in the wetted zone feeds wear debris straight into the slurry as metal contamination and is hard to clean and seal. Metal particles in battery slurry are controlled as a cause of cell short circuits, so wetted-zone bearings are not used.
  • For continuous lines, write the screw-barrel clearance wear measurement method (teardown measurement or drive power trend) and the replacement interval into the contract specification.

Design Checklist

  • Compare shaft deflection δ with clearance c and confirm SF2 of 2 or more
  • Confirm SF1 of 2 or more on bending stress at the same time
  • Confirm the stated scale-up rule (constant tip speed or constant power density)
  • Confirm wetted-part material, surface treatment and metal contamination control (including magnetic filter position)
  • For continuous mixers, confirm the screw-barrel wear measurement method and replacement interval
  • Confirm supplier financial condition and after-sales continuity, including overseas sites

One-line Summary

Comparing mixer makers starts with the clearance-to-deflection ratio and its calculation, not the capacity figure.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top