Battery electrode equipment is the R2R (Roll-to-Roll) family that coats and dries slurry on a current collector (coater), presses it to target density (calender) and cuts it to width and shape (slitter, notcher). The basis for comparing makers is not process coverage but the mechanical structure that holds thickness and width tolerances. This article groups 23 electrode equipment makers verified from public sources by process, and checks by calculation how much calender roll deflection eats into the thickness tolerance.
Problem Definition
Wet coating followed by roll-press calendering is the mainstream electrode process. Makers compete on width and speed. PNT discloses high-speed wide lines of 1,400 mm width at 100 m/min or more, and Haoneng an 1,800 mm ultra-wide two-layer extrusion coater. At the same time, CIS states a guaranteed pressed thickness of ±1.5 µm (company public materials).
Width is the contradiction. A wider line means a longer bearing span and a larger roll deflection. When the gap opens at the center more than at the edges, the electrode gets thicker in the middle. So what should be asked first when comparing wide lines? Our answer: the roll deflection calculation at design load and the crown and bending compensation method.
Kinematic Analysis — Mechanical Issues by Process
| Process | Governing mechanical variable | Typical risk | Makers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coating and drying | Slot-die lip gap, backup roll runout, web tension | Cross-web coat weight variation; curling during drying | Mannest, Sinyoo, Katop, Yakang, Haoneng, Coatema, Faustel, Time High-Tech |
| Calender (roll press) | Roll bending and shear deflection, crown profile, roll thermal expansion | Cross-web thickness variation, wrinkles | CIS, PNT, Matthews |
| Slitting and notching | Knife clearance and overlap, die wear, laser heat-affected zone | Burr, dust, web wander | KAMPF, Maxcess, Hymson, Phil Energy, Youil Energy Tech |
| Inspection | Sensor frame stiffness, scan speed | Loss of measurement repeatability | Dacheng Precision |
| Dry electrode | Speed differential between rolls, film-forming load | Film breakage, poor bonding to the collector | AM Batteries, Matthews, Dürr |
Full-line makers (NAURA, Leadyo, Han’s Lithium, Manz) take the interfaces between processes into their scope. There the comparison is not single-machine specification but how tension zones are split between coater, calender and slitter, and whether the transfer reference surfaces are unified.
Maker Comparison Table
The table lists only what is disclosed on official websites, in filings (DART, exchange annual reports) or in company press releases. Third-party revenue estimates were excluded. Makers with a detailed profile are linked.
| Maker | HQ | Main process | Disclosed facts | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CIS (SFA Nexel) | Daegu, Korea | Coater, calender, slitter | KOSDAQ 222080. Localized the calender in 2008; guarantees ±1.5 µm pressed thickness and slitter burr within 10 µm. 2024 revenue KRW 132.7 billion (roll press 67%) | Company materials, industry press |
| PNT (People & Technology) | Gumi, Korea | Coater, calender, slitter, notcher | KOSDAQ 137400. High-speed wide lines for 6 µm foil, 1,400 mm width, 100 m/min or more. 2025 revenue down 28.0% year on year | DART filings |
| Phil Energy | Gyeonggi, Korea (near Osan) | Stacking, laser notching | KOSDAQ 378340, listed on its own in 2023. Disclosed a KRW 71.19 billion assembly equipment contract in 2026-07 | DART filings |
| Youil Energy Tech | Anseong, Korea | Notching, stacking | KOSDAQ 340930. Founded 2012; notching, stacking and tab welding equipment | DART filings, press |
| Mannest | Shenzhen, China | Coating die heads | ChiNext 301325. No. 1 coating die head maker in China (company statement). 2025 revenue CNY 1.068 billion, net loss CNY 110 million | 2025 annual report |
| Sinyoo | Guangdong, China | Coater (SDC simultaneous double-side coating) | Up to 70 m/min at 1,200 mm coating width, coat weight variation within ±1.0% (company figures) | Company website, OFweek |
| Katop (Jiatuo Intelligent) | Changzhou, China | Electrode and separator coaters | Automation arm of Putailai Group. Double-side high-speed coaters, gravure primer coaters | Company website |
| Yakang Precision | Dongguan, China | Coater, roll press, slitter, winder | Own brand ARECONN. Site 23,500 m², about 900 employees | Company profile materials |
| Haoneng Technology | Shenzhen, China | Coater, roll press | Subsidiary of Keheng (under Gree group). 1,800 mm ultra-wide two-layer extrusion coater | Shanghai Securities News, Sina Finance |
| Shenzhen Time High-Tech | Shenzhen, China | Electrode and cell vacuum drying | Vacuum drying systems to replace hot-air ovens; tab welding equipment | Company website |
| Dacheng Precision | Dongguan, China | Coat weight and thickness gauging, vacuum drying | X-ray/β-ray coat weight gauges, combined CDM thickness and coat weight gauges. Claims over 60% of China’s electrode gauging market (company claim) | instrument.com.cn |
| Hymson | Shenzhen, China | Laser notching and cutting | STAR 688559. Entered with laser tab cutting in 2015. Laser scribing at 80 m/min, over 50 units delivered | Company website, annual report |
| Leadyo | Huizhou, China | Full lines from electrode to assembly | STAR 688499. Built a full solid-state line; won a US module line order in 2024-10 | Company disclosures |
| NAURA | Beijing, China | Lithium battery equipment from mixer to winder (side business) | Shenzhen 002371, China’s largest semiconductor equipment maker. 2023 group revenue CNY 22.08 billion (battery division not disclosed) | Public financials |
| Han’s Lithium | Shenzhen, China | Roll press, die cutting, slitting to formation turnkey | Founded 2018, Han’s Laser (002008) group company | Public industry materials |
| Dürr | Germany | Wet and dry electrode lines | Gained dry coating (X.Cellify DC) through the LiCAP acquisition | electrive, Charged EVs |
| Manz AG | Reutlingen, Germany | Electrode and assembly equipment | Insolvency proceedings opened 2025-02; sites sold separately | Company insolvency notice |
| KAMPF | Wiehl, Germany | Slitters, winders | Founded 1920, Jagenberg subsidiary. TechSlitter rewind diameter up to 800 mm, used by Gränges for cathode foil | Company website |
| Coatema | Dormagen, Germany | R&D and pilot coaters and calenders | ATH Group. Calender working width 100 to 2,000 mm, line force 6 t (pneumatic) to 80 t (hydraulic) | Company website |
| Faustel | Germantown, USA | Modular coating lines | Founded 1956. LabMaster 300 and 600 mm pilot lines; joint turnkey lines with Jagenberg | Company website |
| Matthews International | Pittsburgh, USA | Multi-roll calender for dry electrodes | Nasdaq MATW. Patented system combining calendering and double-side lamination; four calender lines supplied to Evonik Litarion | Company materials |
| Maxcess | Oak Brook, USA | Web guiding and slitting components | Fife guiding, Tidland knife holders and air shafts, MAGPOWR tension control | Company website |
| AM Batteries | Massachusetts, USA | Dry powder deposition (Powder to Electrode) | Founded 2016. Claims 30 to 40% lower capex and 45 to 75% lower energy than wet coating (company figures). First NMC cathode rolls shipped in 2023 | Company announcement |
Coating — the lip gap behind the width and speed race
Coater makers quote width, speed and coat weight variation together. Sinyoo says its SDC method dries both sides at once in a single oven and reduces the curling of shuttle-type two-pass coating. Mannest supplies die heads as separate units. When the die head is bought separately, responsibility for lip gap and backup roll runout is split from the coater body maker, and root-cause isolation of coat weight variation becomes difficult. Tie the die mounting face flatness and backup roll runout allowance into the same contract specification.
Calender — thickness tolerance is the localization benchmark
CIS localized the calender in 2008, and roll presses made up 67% of its 2024 revenue. PNT develops coaters, calenders, slitters and notchers in house. Both are known to have supplied Korea’s three major cell makers. As the calculation below shows, the key point in comparing calenders is the roll deflection compensation method.
Slitting and notching — burr and dust
KAMPF supplies TechSlitter for battery cathode foil, and Maxcess supplies guiding, knife holder and tension control components. Hymson entered with laser notching in 2015 and expanded to electrode-to-assembly lines. Mechanical knives reduce burr through clearance control; lasers avoid die wear but must manage the heat-affected zone and fumes.
Dry electrode — the calender replaces the coater
AM Batteries deposits powder directly on the current collector without solvent. Matthews supplies a multi-roll calender that combines calendering and double-side lamination in one step. In the dry process the drying oven disappears, but the calender takes the entire film-forming load, so calender roll stiffness requirements rise above those of wet lines.
Manz AG entered insolvency proceedings in February 2025 and its sites were sold separately. It shows that supplier financial condition decides spare parts and after-sales continuity.
Calculation and Formula Check — Calender Roll Deflection and Thickness Tolerance
The roll is simplified as a beam simply supported between bearings, with line load spread evenly over the full span. Deflection is the sum of bending and shear components. For a roll whose diameter is large compared with its span, the shear component cannot be ignored.
$$q = \frac{F}{L}, \qquad \delta_b = \frac{5 q L^{4}}{384 E I}, \qquad \delta_s = \frac{\alpha q L^{2}}{8 G A}$$
$q$ is line load (N/mm), $F$ is total press force (N), $L$ is bearing span (mm), $E$ is elastic modulus (N/mm²), $I=\pi D^{4}/64$ is second moment of area (mm⁴), $G$ is shear modulus (N/mm²), $A=\pi D^{2}/4$ is cross-section area (mm²), $\alpha$ is the shear coefficient of a solid circle (10/9) and $D$ is roll diameter (mm).
Example conditions: F=1,000 kN, L=1,400 mm, D=800 mm, E=206,000 N/mm², G=79,000 N/mm². F is an example value; re-confirm actual press force after on-site measurement.
| Item | Value | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Line load q | 714 N/mm | Press force divided by span |
| Bending deflection δb | 8.6 µm | Center of one roll |
| Shear deflection δs | 4.9 µm | About 57% of bending; not negligible |
| Total per roll | 13.5 µm | Upper and lower rolls assumed equal |
| Center gap increase | 27.0 µm | How much the center opens versus the edges |
| Bending stress σb | 3.5 N/mm² | $M=qL^{2}/8$, $Z=\pi D^{3}/32$ |
The safety factor is checked twice. SF1 is the strength criterion. Even with a conservative roll yield strength of 300 N/mm² (assumed; confirm with the material certificate), SF1 is 86. Strength does not govern. SF2 is defined on tolerance.
$$SF_2 = \frac{t_{tol}}{\Delta g}$$
$t_{tol}$ is the allowable thickness variation (µm) and $\Delta g$ is the gap variation remaining after compensation (µm). SF2 below 1 means the tolerance is exceeded. Without compensation, Δg=27.0 µm and SF2 is 0.06 against a ±1.5 µm tolerance. Even if a fixed crown cancels deflection at design load, a ±10% load change leaves Δg of ±2.7 µm, and SF2 is 0.56. A fixed crown is right at only one load. A ±1.5 µm thickness line is hard to hold without variable bending compensation.
Practical Application (Shop-notes)
- When comparing quotations, ask for the roll deflection calculation at design force (bending plus shear), the crown profile and the variable bending range. A calculation that leaves out shear deflection underestimates deflection by 36% in this example.
- Machinability: a crown is a micrometer-level profile, so it needs a CNC roll grinder and measurement after the roll temperature stabilizes. Grind the crown within the hardened case depth so regrinding allowance remains.
- Alternative mechanism — roll crossing (crossed upper and lower roll axes): the crossing angle can compensate the center gap. Not adopted because axial thrust rises with the crossing angle, and thin current collectors are at higher risk of wander and wrinkles. Electrode calenders should consider roll bending cylinders first.
- For slitters, put knife clearance and overlap control criteria and the burr measurement method (location and magnification) into the FAT items.
Design Checklist
- Confirm that the roll deflection calculation includes both bending and shear
- Confirm strength SF1 of 2 or more and tolerance SF2 of 1 or more (after compensation) at the same time
- Compare the fixed crown design load with the actual operating load range
- Confirm the variable bending range and response method
- When buying die heads separately, state the responsibility boundary for mounting face flatness and backup roll runout
- Confirm supplier financial condition and spare parts and after-sales continuity
One-line Summary
Electrode equipment should be compared on the roll gap variation left at design load, not on width and speed.