Battery formation equipment gives an assembled cell its first charge to activate it, then measures capacity through charge and discharge to grade it. The basis for comparing makers is not only channel count and current accuracy. The mechanical structure that keeps racks holding thousands of trays, and probe pins, in position at high temperature decides yield. This article splits 18 formation and cycling equipment makers verified from public sources into production formation and research cyclers, and checks by calculation the shelf deflection and thermal expansion mismatch of a high-temperature formation rack.
Problem Definition
Formation equipment is often classed as power electronics, and makers lead with current accuracy, energy recovery and channel density. Hangke discloses energy-recovery formation and grading systems and high-temperature pressurized charge-discharge technology; Apro focuses on high-temperature pressurized chargers (jig formation).
Temperature is the contradiction. High-temperature formation and aging heat the rack, the trays and the probe pin boards together. A steel frame and an aluminum pin board differ by nearly a factor of two in thermal expansion coefficient. Pin positions set at room temperature drift away from the cell terminals when hot. So what should be asked about formation equipment beyond the electrical specification? Our answer: a pin-to-terminal position error calculation at operating temperature, and a rack deflection calculation.
Kinematic Analysis — Production Formation and Research Cyclers
| Group | Governing mechanical variable | Typical risk | Makers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Production formation and grading (rack type) | Shelf deflection, tray repeatability, probe pin stroke | Poor pin contact; heat from rising contact resistance | Hangke, Titans, Nebula, Neware, Geektest, Wuhan LAND, Wonik PNE, Kapjin, Digatron, Bitrode |
| High-temperature pressurized charging (JF) | Press plate parallelism, holding force, thermal expansion | Uneven cell surface pressure, thickness spread | Apro, Hangke |
| Degassing and EOL inspection | Sealing jig repeatability, vacuum holding | Seal defects, electrolyte contamination | Wonik PNE |
| Research cyclers and testing | Channel density, link to temperature chambers | Temperature variation inside chambers | Arbin, Maccor, BioLogic, BaSyTec, AMETEK, AVL, Jingce |
A production formation line is an automated warehouse of hundreds of rack cells served by tray stacker cranes. Even with identical power electronics, poor positional accuracy of the racks and transfer equipment means more pin re-contacts and retests.
Maker Comparison Table
The table lists only what is disclosed on official websites, in filings, in company press releases or in press reports. Third-party revenue estimates were excluded. Makers whose link to battery formation could not be confirmed in public sources were left out.
| Maker | HQ | Main business | Disclosed facts | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wonik PNE | Korea | Formation, pre-charging, degassing and EOL turnkey; cyclers | No. 1 in Korea’s cycler market (company statement). 76.6% of H1 2023 revenue from battery equipment | Public reports |
| Apro | Korea | High-temperature pressurized chargers (JF) | B2B supply to LG Energy Solution and others. Current ratio fell from 113.3% in 2023 to 87.5% in 2025 | THE VC public data |
| Kapjin | Korea | Chargers and dischargers (back-end) | Founded 1997; customers Samsung SDI and SK On. Filed for rehabilitation in 2025-04; sale in progress | fn Market Watch |
| Hangke Technology | Hangzhou, China | Formation and grading; high-temperature pressurized charging | STAR 688006. Revenue grew from CNY 410 million to CNY 1.11 billion over 2016 to 2018 (listing disclosure). Customers include Samsung SDI, LG Chem, CATL and BYD | Listing disclosure, broker reports |
| Titans New Power | Zhuhai, China | Formation and capacity machines | Acquired by Wuxi Lead in 2017 for CNY 1.35 billion. CNY 915 million CATL formation and capacity machine order in 2018 (combined with Wuxi Lead’s own share) | Wuxi Lead disclosure |
| Nebula (Xingyun) | Fuzhou, China | Charge-discharge testing, formation and grading | ChiNext 300648 (Fujian Nebula Electronics). Stated in 2024-11 that its products apply to solid-state cell testing | Company filings (cninfo), hexun.com |
| Neware | Shenzhen, China | Formation, grading and sorting; test systems | Energy-recovering bidirectional conversion, 24-bit AD conversion (company statement) | Company website |
| Shenzhen Geektest | Shenzhen, China | Formation and grading; module and pack EOL | Production base of over 20,000 m² in Dongguan; registered capital CNY 20 million | Public data |
| Wuhan LAND | Wuhan, China | Battery testing, formation and grading lines | Beijing Stock Exchange 830779 (listed 2023). Entered formation and grading lines in 2022 | Company filings |
| Wuhan Jingce | Wuhan, China | Semiconductor and display inspection; new energy battery systems | Shenzhen 300567. 2023 group revenue CNY 2.43 billion, 2,979 employees | Public financials |
| Digatron | Aachen, Germany | Formation and test systems | Founded 1968, wholly owned by its founder. Covers small cells up to submarine batteries | Company website |
| BaSyTec | Asselfingen, Germany | Cell and module testing | Spun off from the ZSW institute in 1999; over 1,700 systems supplied | Company website |
| BioLogic | Near Grenoble, France | Battery cyclers, potentiostats | Founded 1983, 230 employees. BCS series cyclers | Company website |
| AVL | Graz, Austria | Cell, module and pack testing | Founded 1948. Opened a battery innovation center in 2021. 2020 revenue about EUR 1.7 billion | Company public data |
| Bitrode (Andritz) | Missouri, USA | Formation and testing | Started 1957, now part of Andritz. FTF series up to 1 MW, 4 MW in parallel | Company website |
| Arbin Instruments | Texas, USA | High-precision cyclers | Founded 1991. Nanoampere to 1 MW range. Selected in 2025 to supply test equipment for Ambri’s pilot line | Company announcement |
| Maccor | Tulsa, USA | Battery testers | Founded 1986. EV battery integrated testing partnership with Webasto in 2026-01 | Webasto and Maccor announcement |
| AMETEK | Berwyn, USA | Cyclers, electrochemical instruments | NYSE AME, founded 1930. Regenerative Mi-BEAM and i-BEAM; SI-6200 (2023) | Company website |
Korean makers — turnkey competition and financial risk
Wonik PNE developed in house a turnkey package covering formation, pre-charging, degassing, EOL inspection and logistics. Apro concentrates on high-temperature pressurized chargers. Kapjin filed for rehabilitation in April 2025. Formation orders cluster around cell makers’ expansion schedules, so revenue swings widely. For buyers, who will supply channel boards and pin blocks over the equipment life is a key question.
Chinese makers — energy recovery and vertical integration
Hangke traces its brand to 1984 and supplies energy-recovery formation and grading and high-temperature pressurized charging. Titans New Power was acquired by Wuxi Lead in 2017 and handles the back end of its full lines. Neware and Wuhan LAND expanded from research testing to production formation and grading. When a full-line maker owns the formation maker, the interface between formation racks and upstream transfer equipment is resolved inside one company.
European and US makers — the research and validation market
Digatron and Bitrode focus on production formation systems, while Arbin, Maccor, BioLogic, BaSyTec and AMETEK focus on high-precision research cyclers. AVL runs test infrastructure from cell to pack. Research cyclers offer high per-channel accuracy, but production rack structures and tray handling need separate design.
Calculation and Formula Check — Shelf Deflection and Thermal Mismatch in a Hot Formation Rack
One tray rests on two shelf rails, and each rail is simplified as a simply supported beam under uniform load.
$$w = \frac{m g}{2 L}, \qquad \delta = \frac{5 w L^{4}}{384 E I}, \qquad \sigma = \frac{w L^{2}}{8 Z}$$
$w$ is the distributed load on one rail (N/mm), $m$ is the combined mass of tray and cells (kg), $g$ is 9.81 m/s², $L$ is rail span (mm), $E$ is elastic modulus (N/mm²), $I$ and $Z$ are the rail second moment of area (mm⁴) and section modulus (mm³), $\delta$ is deflection (mm) and $\sigma$ is bending stress (N/mm²).
Example conditions: m=80 kg, L=1,000 mm, steel rail with I=2.0×10⁵ mm⁴ and Z=8.0×10³ mm³, E=206,000 N/mm². All are example values; re-confirm after on-site measurement. Results: w=0.392 N/mm, δ=0.124 mm, σ=6.1 N/mm². With SS275 rails (yield strength 275 N/mm², KS D 3503), SF1 is 45. With a pin compression stroke margin of 0.5 mm (example), the deflection-based SF2 is 4.0. Both criteria pass under room-temperature load.
Temperature is the problem. Assume the rack and the pin board are both fixed at the center, and look at the thermal mismatch.
$$\Delta x = \frac{(\alpha_{al}-\alpha_{st})\, L\, \Delta T}{2}$$
$\Delta x$ is the position error of the end pin (mm), $\alpha_{al}$=23.1×10⁻⁶/°C (aluminum), $\alpha_{st}$=11.7×10⁻⁶/°C (steel), $L$ is pin board length (mm) and $\Delta T$ is the temperature rise from room temperature (°C). With L=1,000 mm and ΔT=35°C (25°C to 60°C, example condition), Δx=0.20 mm.
| Check item | Calculated | Criterion | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rail bending stress SF1 | 45 | 2 or more | Pass |
| Rail deflection SF2 (against 0.5 mm pin stroke) | 4.0 | 2 or more | Pass |
| Thermal end error Δx | 0.20 mm | 1.5x margin against 0.3 mm position allowance (example) | Below 2x margin |
The load criteria have ample margin. But thermal mismatch alone uses two thirds of the position allowance, before tray repeatability error and cell terminal position spread are added. In a hot formation rack, thermal mismatch governs, not load. Doubling the pin board length doubles the end error.
Practical Application (Shop-notes)
- When comparing quotations, ask for a pin-to-terminal position error stack-up at operating temperature (thermal expansion, tray repeatability, cell terminal spread). Do not rank a proposal with room-temperature alignment data only in the same class.
- Countermeasure priority: match the materials of pin board and supporting frame, or fix the pin board at one central point with slotted holes at both ends to absorb expansion.
- Machinability: at slotted joints, limit bolt axial force with shoulder bolts or spacers so clamping does not stop sliding. Specify slot width and shoulder length tolerances on the drawing to avoid play after assembly.
- Alternative mechanism — let the whole pin board float (free in four directions) and locate it every time with tray locating pins. Not adopted because accumulated wear of locating pins and bushings degrades repeatability, and a rack with thousands of positions ends up with too many wear points to manage.
- For high-temperature pressurized chargers, add press plate parallelism measured at operating temperature to the FAT items.
Design Checklist
- Confirm the pin-to-terminal position error stack-up at operating temperature
- Confirm the pin board and frame material pairing and fixing method (central fix, slotted holes)
- Confirm shelf rail bending SF1 and deflection SF2 of 2 or more each
- Confirm tray repeatability and the wear management interval of locating pins
- Confirm whether press plate parallelism is measured at operating temperature
- Confirm continuity of channel board and pin block spares and supplier financial condition
One-line Summary
When comparing hot formation equipment, check first whether the pins hold the terminals at operating temperature, before current accuracy.